Vegan Zero Waste Black Mascara

The only thing good about this mascara is that it’s zero waste. What a mess! It rubs off under and over eye, is hard to apply, would be hard to store if I was keeping it. It’s frustrating that they are offering this low quality product as an alternative.

Love the packaging and color.

Not entirely pleased with this product. It seems to transfer to under eye area

I like using this mascara and love that it came in eco-friendly packaging with a reusable and eco-friendly brush. The mascara itself is light weight and doesn’t seem to smudge too much. Sometimes it can be a little chunky but that might be user error as I learn to roll it on the brush. I do wonder if it will get too difficult to roll the brush in it once the top layers have been used, since the container is more of a puck than a tube (you can’t “dip” the brush in like other mascaras). But I am willing to keep using it and figure it out when it comes to that. Overall, if you’re looking for sustainable make-up and don’t mind trying something a little unconventional, I’d recommend this product.

I think I can make this mascara work, but it does not go on very thick or make very dark lashes. I am blonde, so my lashes are very light and this mascara will give me enough color for everyday wear. I read other reviews that the mascara comes off and leaves a dark circle around the eyes but that is not my experience - mine is the opposite, that it is hard to get enough on. I do feel great about not having a plastic container with a small amount of product in it. This cardboard container is great and I think it will last a long time. It didn't come with any directions - it might be helpful to know if there's a trick to putting it on to get thicker lashes.